As an AP who has talked with other APs, my guess is that Tama is closer to the AP mainstream that you’d think (and hope). Look at the responses to the original post from APs. Since the comments have been closed on the post, it’s hard for anyone - adult adoptees, KADs, or others - to let their voices be heard.
I agree with Bob, I find Tama to be VERY mainstream attitude.
If you read the comments on the first piece by Jeff Gammage (I couldn’t even stomach to read the second) you will see the line of AP’s rushing to high-five the sentimental orientalist tone of his essay.
I just spoke with an aquantance who has two bio kids and was in the process of adopting from Vietnam. Evidently the program is making some changes and therefore the process is longer so they have opted to not proceed. The thing that go me - an AP of a child adopted from Guatemala - was that he said they were very sad to have made this decision and that they were just tying to do some “good” - I stared at him in shock! That was the reason you were adopting, and your social worker let you get away with that. From my perspective (we did not adopt to save a child, we adopted so we could be parents and have a family) their social worker didn’t properly educate them, and this may be because they were working with a religious based adoption agency.
So, I’d agree there are many AP’s who have the same view point as Tama, but there are just as many who don’t. And those of us who don’t need to speak up and be heard.
At first glance, I decided that the Relative Choices blog was a waste of my time and a very sad excuse of a representation of “Adoption and the American Family”. I am definitely one of the offended APs.
Anti-Racist Parent is a blog for parents who are committed to raising children with an anti-racist outlook. Comments on this blog are moderated. Please read our comment moderation policy.
Carmen’s perspectives on race and racism have been featured in Newsweek, USA Today, MSNBC Live, and NPR’s News & Notes. You can reach her at 917.657.3886 or carmen@newdemographic.com.
Natasha wrote:
Why are the only people up in arms about this adult adoptees? Where are all the angry and offended APs? Tana’s not really AP mainstream, is she?
http://multiracialsky.wordpress.com/2007/11/14/where-are-the-outraged-parents-here/
Posted 14 Nov 2007 at 2:17 pm ¶
Bob S wrote:
As an AP who has talked with other APs, my guess is that Tama is closer to the AP mainstream that you’d think (and hope). Look at the responses to the original post from APs. Since the comments have been closed on the post, it’s hard for anyone - adult adoptees, KADs, or others - to let their voices be heard.
Posted 14 Nov 2007 at 2:28 pm ¶
Jae Ran wrote:
I agree with Bob, I find Tama to be VERY mainstream attitude.
If you read the comments on the first piece by Jeff Gammage (I couldn’t even stomach to read the second) you will see the line of AP’s rushing to high-five the sentimental orientalist tone of his essay.
Posted 15 Nov 2007 at 8:15 am ¶
amy wrote:
I just spoke with an aquantance who has two bio kids and was in the process of adopting from Vietnam. Evidently the program is making some changes and therefore the process is longer so they have opted to not proceed. The thing that go me - an AP of a child adopted from Guatemala - was that he said they were very sad to have made this decision and that they were just tying to do some “good” - I stared at him in shock! That was the reason you were adopting, and your social worker let you get away with that. From my perspective (we did not adopt to save a child, we adopted so we could be parents and have a family) their social worker didn’t properly educate them, and this may be because they were working with a religious based adoption agency.
So, I’d agree there are many AP’s who have the same view point as Tama, but there are just as many who don’t. And those of us who don’t need to speak up and be heard.
Posted 16 Nov 2007 at 10:15 am ¶
Krystal wrote:
At first glance, I decided that the Relative Choices blog was a waste of my time and a very sad excuse of a representation of “Adoption and the American Family”. I am definitely one of the offended APs.
Posted 18 Nov 2007 at 12:21 am ¶