To be a lost child

by Anti-Racist Parent Columnist Michelle Myers

“. . . well, enough rage and helplessness, and your love turns to something else. . . . It turns to steaming piss.”
-Mitchell Stephens in The Sweet Hereafter

“I’m telling you this . . . because we’ve all lost our children . . . . They’re dead to us. . . . Something terrible has happened that’s taken our children away. It’s too late. They’re gone.”
-Mitchell Stephens in The Sweet Hereafter
I am a lost child.

I recently had a birthday. However, when my parents called to wish me a “Happy Birthday,” I wasn’t really glad to hear from them. I actually was irritated with them because neither had called on my son’s third birthday, which we had also just celebrated. I’d been thinking they didn’t call because, despite whatever excuses they might give, he’s the darkest of my three children, and I suspect they don’t feel very connected to him. Probably to them he’s the one grandchild they would identify most as “black” although he’s also the most Asian-looking. I didn’t say this to my mom, though, when she asked me why I hadn’t called in a while. I simply told her, “You didn’t call to tell Victor ‘Happy Birthday,’ so I didn’t know what was going on.” Her response was that “He’s too young to know it’s his birthday,” so “What difference does it make?” I told her that not only did he understand it was his birthday, but he would have been excited just to talk to her on the phone. She had no response, and I have learned over the years that it doesn’t pay to argue. So I said nothing else. When my dad got on the phone to wish me “Happy Birthday,” he said, “I can’t believe my little girl is 35.” I wanted to say, “I haven’t been your ‘little girl’ for a long time.” But instead, I just said, “Uh-huh.” Before the conversation ended, my mom told me I should call more often.

I want to be there for my parents because, despite things, I do love them and have a sense of duty to them: they aren’t getting any younger, and I live close enough to be there in case of an emergency (my brother lives in Colorado). But after so many turned down holiday invitations, missed birthdays, inappropriate criticisms, and uncountable years of “history,” a part of me has distanced myself from my parents so that I could cut them off—if I felt I had to. Too many unforgivable things have happened over the years. And while I may not hate them so much anymore, I am lost to them on many levels.

The last time I wrote a post, I had asked a question about parental accountability: as parents, how can we conduct ourselves in a way that won’t cause our children to hate us? First, I should be clear that in asking this question, I’m not saying that parents should yield to their children’s every desire and whim to make them happy—I’m not saying that at all. I’m talking about something totally different, something deeper. I’m talking about not appearing as hypocrites and cowards to our children in matters of race, ethnicity, culture (and even religion, gender/sexuality, morals/values) so that they come to question their own identities and even come to hate themselves, for please understand that oftentimes when children recognize that they hate themselves, they place responsibility or blame for that foremost on their parents.

I also don’t want to come off sounding like this is some self-righteous sermon. I think I should be clear that my context for asking these questions and raising these points comes from my being a mixed-race daughter of parents who, despite being in an interracial marriage, held/hold hypocritical and racist views about others, especially in terms of telling me who I was/am and who I should/could have relationships with. I had asserted in my last post that I would use myself as an example of how children can develop feelings of anger and hate (or hate-love) for their parents, but as I’ve been thinking about this more, I’ve been unsure how to adequately explain why I have hated my parents at various times during my life in a way that would illuminate the concerns and warnings I’m trying to present to readers of this blog.

In trying to figure out the best way to start off these discussions without it disintegrating into some “poor me” sob story, I came across one of the first poems I wrote as an adult. Never did I think I would share this poem like I’m about to; originally, it was something I had written specifically for my students at the time, many who had lived extremely difficult lives throughout their childhoods, for trusting me with their most personal stories. But now I post it here so perhaps you can know, just a little bit, where I’m coming from as I continue to talk about this issue of anger and hate (I’m planning my next two posts around this topic). You have to realize there is a huge community of people (children from interracial relationships, children from transracial adoptions, 2nd generation children of immigrant parents, children of racists, etc) who are angry and full of hate. If left unresolved, they are willing to destroy all family ties. In the end, they may destroy themselves. I know some of you might think this won’t or can’t happen to you, but I’m sure most parents do not imagine that their children could grow up to really despise them.

Anyway, I wrote this poem when I was 23. Obviously, it provides only a fragmented picture in many different ways, compresses all these bad events together to seem as if there were no happy times (which there were), and is more critical of my father than my mother even though my mother’s racial views were not much different from my father’s. I also don’t want to come off as trying to project myself as a complete victim or to make excuses for myself: I know I have faults of my own which are not presented in this poem. Therefore, I don’t want anything from you for myself—no sympathy, empathy, pity, validation. But the poem is indicative of a frame of mind and a kind of relationship, and I just hope that, as parents, you learn something productive from it. Finally, these life experiences inform my own struggles as a parent trying to determine ways to help my three mixed-race children as they navigate through the challenges of being mixed.

I am a lost child, but my children don’t have to be.

Untitled

I was born—
Seoul, South Korea. My mother is Korean; my father white. American.
Coming to America. I am about a-year-old.
Salem, NJ. Carpenter Street. A lot of black people.
My father is an alcoholic. He hits my mom. My brother and me too.
Whippings, belts, buckles.

The dogs chase the black people as they walk passed the yard.
We move out of Salem—away from the black people.
Now in Woodstown.
I am four.

My father is an alcoholic. He comes home and passes out on the lawn.
My mom gets beaten. We get beatings.
But my mom drives around all night looking for him when he doesn’t come home from work. Sometimes she leaves us alone. Sometimes, we go.
I am the oldest so I go in the bars to get him.

Starting elementary school. I am not allowed to have black friends.
Many birthday parties I did not go to.
It is a week before my birthday. I am seven.
My uncle is eighteen. He is murdered. By his best friend.
Shot in the head.
His body is found behind Salem High School.
My dad identifies the body.
My family can’t stop crying.
We move away. Running.

No more public school—too many black people in Penns Grove.
Catholic school—we are not Catholic.
Everyone else is Catholic. Everyone else is white.
Suddenly, I am a “chink.”
Not many friends. Just books.
Year-after-year of seemingly non-stop reading.

I am ugly. So ugly.
They tell me. My mom tells me. No one loves me.
I hate my mother.

My father is an alcoholic.
He wakes me up in the middle of the night. He talks about my uncle.
He cries. He scares me when he is drunk, either hitting or crying, us never knowing which will come.
He hates my mother.
I hate my mother.
It’s all her fault no one likes me—I want to be white.
She has messed up my life.
My “chinky” eyes—I am so ugly.
I want to be loved.

Eighth grade graduation—party. Alcohol.
I am almost gang-raped . . . by five guys I grew up with.
They stopped because my screaming turned them off.
I’m fourteen.
My parents find out. They are humiliated. They blame me.
“You shouldn’t have been drinking”
“You shouldn’t have been alone with boys.”
No charges filed.

Public high school—no money to send me to Catholic school anymore.
I’m scared. So many black people.
First “real” boyfriend. He is white.
I lose my virginity, reluctantly.
I am still fourteen.

My father is an alcoholic. I am on my way.
Drinking with my father. Cool.
Wake up one morning covered with my own vomit.
I could have died. I will not drink again.

My goodness . . . he has a nice smile.
It’s wrong—all wrong. They’re supposed to be “bad.”
“Dirty”
But . . . he is so nice to me.
My first black boyfriend. I am fifteen.
Now I am a “nigger-lover.”
My dad and my mom and me constantly fight.

My father is an alcoholic. He is violent. Even when he is not drunk.
One night, I call him a “motherfucker.” He
bashes my head into a towel rack in the bathroom.
I run way from home (first time).
I stay with my aunt.
My grandmother calls—the white one.
She’s sick—in the hospital.
But my parents have told her.
My aunt’s crying. My uncle’s yelling—
“You NIGGER-LOVER!”
“I won’t have a NIGGER-LOVER in my house!”
He’s an alcoholic too.

I go back home. I date. I lie.
I say forget it. Hatred all around me.
My white grandmother begs me to get along with my dad.
She cries. “Your dad has had a hard life,” she says.
“He needs to be happy.”
Feeling guilty, I make a promise.
She dies soon after.
Cut off black friends. Puerto Rican friends.
A new white boyfriend—from another town.
His family tells nigger jokes. Spic jokes. Chink jokes. Dot-head jokes.
My parents are so happy. I am seventeen.

College by chance—full scholarship.
My father is still an alcoholic. He still hates my mom.
My mom is so miserable. She cries all the time. I listen to her.
I begin to love my mother.
Korea—stories—a world, a people. It’s all me.
I want to know more.
My Korean grandmother visits.
My white boyfriend refuses to say hello in Korean.
You will not be my father. I will not have a husband like my father.

Racists. Hypocrites. Racists. Hypocrites.
Not for my children.
They will be proud. They will not want to be white.
I really hate. I am twenty.

I want to be strong.
I want to be strong.
I want to be . . .
So much to deal with—just get good grades. Graduate. 3.959 GPA.
Full Fellowship to Temple. Get me out of here.
I am twenty-three.

My father is still an alcoholic. He threatened to kill her.
I’ll take her away someday. I have strength enough to do that.
I try not to hate, but I am angry. And I don’t trust.
I try to make myself untouchable.
You can’t touch me.
It’s all for the better, I think.
Then I won’t feel the burrs, stones, or teeth as
I run with the wolves inside of me.

Michelle Myers holds a Ph.D. in English from Temple University, specializing in Asian American Literature. She is a founding member of the spoken word poetry group Yellow Rage, which was featured on HBO’s RUSSELL SIMMONS PRESENTS DEF POETRY, and which recently released its second CD: HANDLE WITH CARE, VOL. 2. She is also a founding member of the performance collective Asians Misbehavin’. She is currently an Assistant Professor at Community College of Philadelphia and Grants Coordinator at SEAMAAC (Southeast Asian Mutual Assistance Associations Coalition). Michelle lives in NJ with her husband, Tyrone, and their three children: Myong, Victor, and Vanessa.

Share and Enjoy:These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • del.icio.us
  • digg
  • YahooMyWeb
  • Furl
  • NewsVine
  • Reddit
  • co.mments

Trackbacks & Pings

  1. What are the unique challenges of parenting multiracial children? at Anti-Racist Parent - for parents committed to raising children with an anti-racist outlook on 19 Mar 2007 at 7:00 am

    […] between difference and ideas about “normality.” Michelle Myers wrote a deep post on Anti-Racist Parent about how and why a multiracial child might not even find community in that most basic of places, […]

  2. When hospitals host family reunions: More about how racism destroys families at Anti-Racist Parent - for parents committed to raising children with an anti-racist outlook on 09 May 2007 at 8:23 am

    […] head with a shotgun, and then he killed himself with it. It happened the day after I had emailed my last post to Carmen, and she had told me it would go up at the end of that same week. When my mom called me […]

Comments

  1. Katie wrote:

    Michelle - you are so right about the hate and the pain that we can feel. From my experience, I think one way to prevent this would simply be to talk about race and racism (I guess it helps not to be a racist for this one, so my Mom and Dad would fail) and to support your child against the racism that they’ll encounter.

    My parents used the tactic of simply not talking about things that might be problematic - race, sex, drugs, etc. - until it was far too late. Living in an all-White town didn’t help either. Now, as a biracial Korean American who identifies strongly with other women of color, I am floored that my parents just never addressed the racism that I experienced every day in school. Silence does not erase difference, and I have been angry at my parents for my whole life because of that.

  2. Kim wrote:

    The idea that family is truly a place of refuge, solace; a bed of nurturing and enduring support, is simply another myth we have to decode for ourselves, when we are ready.

    For all the ways you were able to step away from the chaos and still thrive and accomplish things in the world, things which define and place you and your interests, your core philosophies, your truths as expressed by your actions and words, there is still that tether, drawn in our psyches as a breathing tube, a pulsing, pumping life support system.

    If you don’t find it to be so, don’t invest so much in it. Is that easy? No. But when we continue to let other people into our lives…our inner lives…and continue the hurtful dynamic, hoping our example will change them, I don’t see that as being true to self.

    A parent is a person who made choices, even if that means having chosen to let another make choices for them.

    Make the choices that heal and affirm your central place as mother, and if others want to be near you, need you like that, maybe they will come to you, on different terms.

    Your healing as daughter cannot be done unilaterally, I know. But daughter is not all you are anymore, either.

  3. Jae Ran wrote:

    Thank you for this post. It actually brought up a lot of things I wanted to write but I just can’t bring myself to do so. This is the third time trying to respond.

    All I can say is I really appreciate your sharing and your question. I struggle with this as a parent. Sadly, I think that my response as a parent to some of the issues you’ve brought up is to do the opposite of what my own parents did with me. So far, my kids and I are very close, even as my daughter and I are starting the classic mother/teenage daughter tumultuous years. I guess only time will tell, but so far, we’re very close while at her age I was trying to get as far away from my parents as possible.

    I was one of those transracially adopted kids who at age 18 walked out the door, relieved I’d never have to go back. I was willing then to sever my relationship with my parents forever.

    As I’ve grown up, I’ve been able to reconcile some with my parents but they still don’t get it in so many ways (as I’ve mentioned in my post about spending holidays with them) that I’ve at times thought about not allowing my kids to spend time around them. Because their families should be a refuge and the safe place for them, not the source of their pain and alienation.

  4. Kaywil wrote:

    Pain is a very powerful emotion. Sometimes it’s just what we need to feel to change things for the better. Thank you for sharing your emotions and your experience with us.

  5. Mandy wrote:

    This is a conversation me and my daughters birthmother have been having. Not so much about race but about how to raise our children so they don’t grow up to hate us like we hate our parents. We are both terrified that dispite what we do our children will grow up to hate us. Our parents say they did the best they could and we are doing the best we can so who’s to say our children still won’t grow to hate us?

    My husband and I are caucasian and adopted and African American little girl almost 2 years ago and this past October I came to a painful realization that my mother did not like my daughter and I am afraid it is because of her skin color. She had made comments that I tried to overlook but once sitting down and thinking about it realized that when Asha is older and understands some of the things grandma is saying it will hurt her. I decided that I would rather Asha not have a grandma than to have one that hates her. I have broken all ties with my mother for that and alot of other reasons but it hurts that she couldn’t love my daughter regardless of her skin color. My daughter is amazing and loves with all her heart and my mother will never feel that love.

    I do hate my mom and I just hope that my daughter grows up to love me and we can always be close because everything I do I do in her best interest. I can’t say the same for my mother.

  6. Kim wrote:

    Mandy…

    is that a hate arising from a series of incidents, a lifelong build-up of things which would not go away, or from your recognition of her lack of good feelings toward your daughter?

    While I am not in the same situation as you, my husband is with his mother, and all I can say to you is recognizing that you have so seriously disturbed her comfort zone, that she may never have had the challenge, the opportunity, to confront the deep-held feelings she is displaying and revealing in her relationship to her granddaughter.

    I do not seek to excuse your mother, nor do I excuse my husband’s mother. It has been a long, solo journey he has walked to understand that she will never change, and that the person she raised him to be is not the person she herself could ever truly be in her protected, privileged life. She didn’t have to be -until his children, and now the path to reconciling how she presents (or does not) versus how she projects, is one which pains him deeply, and is felt by each of us indirectly, due to the loss of having a relationship with that member of the extended family.

    Sometimes holding on to a core of hate keeps you tied to the other in a way that blocks you, and can even consume you. Your daughter would be impacted by that, as well. (I felt you so strongly through your words, it was almost palpable.)

    Peace.

  7. Kim wrote:

    Oh, Mandy…

    I hadn’t seen the ‘lot of other reasons’ portion of your text, so that answers the first part of my prior post.

    -K

  8. Mandy wrote:

    Kim~

    My mother would never admit that my daughters skin color is her problem but her comments have lead us to believe that is indeed her problem. My mother’s feelings towards her granddaughter are just the cherry on top of alot of problems with her.

    I do feel strong hate for her but I am slowly getting to the point that I don’t think about her much anymore and I do know that she will never change so distancing my family from her is for the best. I’m just scared that my daughter will grow up some day to hate me. You post brought about all those insecure mommy feelings for me that my beautiful little girl may feel towards me as I do towards my mother. I would never do to my daughter what my mother has done to me but it still scares me. This article/post just brought up all the insecurity but it is nice to see that there are other mothers out there who feel that way as well.

    Also my mothers behavior was effecting both of my children, I also have a stepson who lives with us, to the point that my step son did not want her at his birthday party. That’s a pretty good sign to me that she is hurting them as well as me. I have cut her out of our lives for all of our sanity and well being.

    Thanks for your conern and I am so sorry to hear that your husbands mother is giving him problems too. It’s so sad when the people you are supposed to be able to depend on aren’t there for you.

  9. Kim wrote:

    Oh, no…never meant to do that. Just to say that in giving away too much of yourself to that ‘other’ situation, you take some essential focus and unbound mirth away from your interactions in all of life.

    Kind of like…it’s pretty hard to NOT think about something if it is ALL we think about, which I don’t think most of us do.

    Your stepson is far more aware of when to back away than my husband, (then again, like I said, it is my husband’s intimate issue, and not mine) who spent way too many years believing that his mother’s silence and aversion, her turning away from and open disregard toward him and the children (hmm, toward me, too, but I never think of her THAT way, so…), her lavishing gifts and welcoming invitations on the other grandkids, would somehow mean less than the sum of their parts. She’s never spoken an unkind word, so it took a while for his heart to hear through the silence.

    Thanks. Glad you’re here. Did I say Asha is a beautiful name? Asha is a beautiful name.

  10. Ayala wrote:

    “The idea that family is truly a place of refuge, solace; a bed of nurturing and enduring support, is simply another myth we have to decode for ourselves, when we are ready.”

    Kim, this is the wisest, most mind-blowing, life-altering thing I’ve read in YEARS. I would love to know your last name so that I can quote it often and extensively and give it proper attribution.

  11. Kim wrote:

    Ayala…email me.

    I’m glad it did not totally paint me as heretic, and find that, life-long, it has been the easiest way to accept that people come to me as they are, and don’t have to fill the needs I have and had written for them to fill.

    Trying to stay under the radar of the can-in-the-meat-cyber hogs: using yahoo, you can reach me at afroceltclan.

    Thanks for the support, and the contact, in your comment.

  12. Mandy wrote:

    Kim~ Thanks for the compliment on Asha’s name. Her birthmom wanted a name that meant something so we named her Asha which means “life” in Africa. It was actually pretty amazing that we picked this name because she was born on Easter Sunday as well. She was 2 weeks early so she wasn’t originally due on Easter.

    It usually does take men a little longer to figure out what the silence and little silent messages mean. My DH is still bling to alot of things his mother has said or done to him because they aren’t always verbal. My mother was VERY verbal about how she felt and that’s why my stepson caught on so quickly that grandma was having problems with us. Not so much problems with Asha but just my whole family and the way we do things.

    I really enjoyed your post and I look forward to hearing more of your thoughts.

  13. Nachita wrote:

    I am reminded of my own inner healing work in the areas of taking responsibility for myself as I parented two now grown daughters. They both speak of me with admiration but I also speak of them in the same way. And I wonder how I did it…

    I can say my husband helped. He is African American and I am Mexican American. He taught our daughters of the wonderful cultural strengths of African Americans in this country and Africa. I taught them about the rich history of my people. And we did not try to smooth over the truth and history of the United States in the areas of racial oppression.

    I am an anti-racist educator –I have been doing this work for about 20 years and I believe this education and life practice has also helped me.

    I wish you well in your search for healing and additional strength. (You have been healing for some time now and are already very strong, but you do know that, don’t you?…)

  14. midnightships wrote:

    1. Mandy, after your comment re: “Asha” meaning “life” in Africa, I just had to respond firstly to that. Africa is a HUGE continent and stating that anything is African, doesn’t remotley provide an accurate picture of its history, its contemporary usage, etc. Trawling through the web, the most common sites that make the effort to be specific state that “Asha” means “life” in Swahili (indicating its East African origins) or “hope” in Sanskrit (the Indian/Asian side of it). My experience with the name comes from my mother’s family who are Sierra Leonean Muslims. Therefore, I am more familiar with variations such as: Iesha, Isha, Aisha….

    2. Wrt the post, it’s heartbreaking to realise that the people who are supposed to provide a cushion to the world’s bumps and scrapes, turn out to be the most vindictive and soul-destroying individuals we could ever hope not to meet. I think that hating someone puts too much power into their hands and allows her/him to continue to hurt long after we have cut ourselves off from their physical presence. However, I fully agree with the decision to cut yourselves off from family members who cannot even manage to perform the most basic instinct found in living organisms–that is, to protect the young. Human beings proclaim to be the most intelligent creatures on the planet, yet we routinely experience adults physically, emotionally and verbally harming children–because?

  15. Daniel wrote:

    This is a tough one. I can certainly relate. I have three children and my father has never called to speak with any of them. He has never seen them except from a few photos that I have sent him. He recently started sending gifts on Christmas which is nice and I know he is trying. Last year, I discovered that he took a trip to LA to see my sister and her new baby; his competely white grandson. My oldest daughter is black and my two youngest children are puerto rican. He’s never taken a trip to see them. Their ages are 19, 10 and 4. He’s had plenty of time. When I sent him some pictures, he wrote that I had a beautiful family. He still hasn’t called. He wants me to call him. I haven’t been able to yet.

    Daniel

  16. Samantha wrote:

    Your poem is very moving. I actually felt kind of guilty for being white. This just reminds me of how my aunt thinks that all people of middle eastern descent are terrorists, well blatently forgetting that her mother was lebanese. Which just so happens to be in the middle east. Or the time that my second cousin asked me if I thought that her grandmother was rascist (her grandmother was a little freaked when she found out that she had a black boyfriend). I told her that yes, of course I thought that her grandma was rascist. It seems that if we could just glorify our differences and unify, then we would have much less in the way of problems in this world.

  17. Kim wrote:

    Daniel…

    those little ‘discoveries’ can just kill you, can’t they?

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared.